Verdict For Medical Malpractice $103 Million
Failure To Diagnose Cancer $3 Million
Brooklyn Elevator Malfunction $1 Million Medical Malpractice During Surgery $3.9 Million Man Paralyzed In Two-Car Collision
$5 Million
Man Paralyzed In Two-Car Collision $2.9 Million Pedestrian Struck and Injured By Vehicle
$1.1 Million
Plaintiff Sustains Injury On Employers Premises $1.7 Million Plaintiff Hit By Vehicle Riding A Motorcycle $600 Thousand
Plaintiff Fell On Poorly Waxed Floor At Bank $900 Thousand

Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyers

Choosing the right Law firm matters.

In a city of eight million people, there are tens of thousands of lawyers. Every day of the week, individuals and businesses need legal help. When that someone is you, rest assured that the lawyers at Sgarlato & Sgarlato have the legal expertise to obtain the best possible results for our clients.



What We Do

Insurance companies notice when cases are handled by paralegals or case managers. We’re different – all letters, conversations and negotiations are handled by an attorney only. Period.


Our Approach

Too many cases mean less focus on you. To achieve larger outcomes, we focus on quality not quantity – more time into fewer cases for better results. Our testimonials speak to the better experience at every stage!


Our Mission

We have the resources to give your case the time and energy it deserves. We never pressure clients into accepting bad settlement offers. We are prepared to do whatever it takes to secure a maximum recovery for you!

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

For someone who is unfamiliar with the area of personal injury law, it can be a confusing subject. What are the statutes of limitations on the various types of personal injury cases and how to those change if it is a case brought against the government? Should I give any information to the insurance company or discuss the case in any way? The area of personal injury law can be a minefield that is impossible to navigate if you don’t have experienced professionals on your side.

Construction Accidents

At Sgarlato and Sgarlato, we have years of experience in handling a variety of personal injury cases. We have the expertise you need to get the best possible results for your case. Whether your case involves a government entity or a private individual, you need to contact the expert Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyers at Sgarlato and Sgarlato because time is not on your side in a personal injury case.

Medical Malpractice

If there is one person people trust implicitly outside of their own family members it is their doctor. When that doctor recommends their patient go see a specialist, that patient also trusts the specialist implicitly. When a doctor violates that trust, it can be emotionally devastating for the patient. But more than that, it can also be fatal.

Legal Malpractice

It takes a special kind of law firm to be the legal malpractice attorney Staten Island residents and business professionals count on. But for many years now, Sgarlato and Sgarlato has been the legal malpractice lawyer Staten Island clients have been counting for honest and comprehensive representation.

Our Office

Over 50 years of combined experience
in complex legal matters

At Sgarlato & Sgarlato, we are Staten Island personal injury lawyers dedicated to our clients and will fight to ensure a fair and equitable outcome. Our attorneys have more than 75 years of combined experience. Sgarlato & Sgarlato’s exceptional results for our clients lie in the expertise, professionalism and ingenuity of each of our exceptionally qualified attorneys.The results we achieve for our clients often make headlines.

Success Stories

Because of Mr. Sgarlato, my life is changing for the better. The award we won against the hospital will help me do whatever I want to do in life and give me a little more freedom.

- Stephanie Debes

I’ve known Richard and Gina Sgarlato for thirty years and rely on them to handle every kind of legal issue. They assist me and my family in real estate matters and property investments.
- Dennis Gambinio

During one of the most painful times in my life, the Sgarlato firm corrected the mistakes of another law firm and obtained the best possible result in the wrongful death of my husband.

- Carol Spatola

Get In Touch

    How to respond to a social media lawsuit at your business

    Social media can be a handy tool when it comes to scaling your business - whether it is promoting your business or converting potential leads. However, the many blush and bliss of social media can ultimately turn out to be a tiring uphill run, especially when dealing...

    Hearing Loss – When Is It Too Late To Claim

    Do you know that if you wait too long to seek hearing loss compensation, you might lose it? There are strict time limits for filing a court action, and failure to do so results in the loss of the right to compensation. Since the case is time-barred, it cannot be...

    Wrongful Birth Claims Against Doctors

    Giving birth to a defective child can be a very frustrating situation as parents of defective children live with the outcome for a lifetime. And most times, depending on the severity of such congenital disabilities, it can negatively affect how parents interact with...

    What to do after a car accident in New York

    What to do after a car accident in New York Car accidents are quite rampant in New York, with reports from the New York Department of Health stating car accidents are responsible for 91-percent of the death occurrence throughout the state.  Car accidents are quite the...

    Sgarlato – Pre-Medical Offers – What Are They And Should You Accept Them?

    If you have received a pre-medical offer, this is good news and shows that your claim is being taken seriously by the defendant's insurance company. It often happens following a personal injury incident that may have occurred at work or perhaps caused by a negligent...

    Can I Claim for an Allergic Reaction Injury?

    According to AAFA, about 7.7 percent of adults were diagnosed with hay fever in 2018, making allergic reactions the 6th leading cause of chronic illness. When you have an allergy, you’re likely to avoid foods or situations that trigger an allergic reaction. But it...

    Should I accept a settlement offer?

    Should I accept a settlement offer? Personal injury accidents can be confounding, and sadly enough, it always happens when you least expect it. If you or someone you know was involved in an accident, the best action is to file for a personal injury claim. Soon, you...

    The Scales of Justice symbol

    The Scales of Justice symbol is an ancient symbol dating back to Roman times. It represents the balance between truth and fairness. It represents freedom from prejudice, greed, and corruption. Justice is supposedly blind,...

    Governor Cuomo Signs Executive Order 202.55

    Moments ago, Governor Cuomo signed Executive Order 202.55 By this Executive Order, any specific time limit for the commencement, filing, or service of any legal action, notice, motion, or other process or proceeding, as prescribed by the procedural laws of the state,...

    Child Victim’s Act

    Moments ago, A9036 Rosenthal/S7082 Hoylman extending the Child Victim’s Act was sent to Governor Andrew Cuomo. The Governor now has 10 days to sign or veto the bill. This extension to August 14, 2021 ensures that victims who have not yet been able...