Failure To Diagnose Cancer $3 Million
Brooklyn Elevator Malfunction $1 Million Medical Malpractice During Surgery $3.9 Million Man Paralyzed In Two-Car Collision
$5 Million
Man Paralyzed In Two-Car Collision $2.9 Million Pedestrian Struck and Injured By Vehicle
$1.1 Million
Plaintiff Sustains Injury On Employers Premises $1.7 Million Plaintiff Hit By Vehicle Riding A Motorcycle $600 Thousand
Plaintiff Fell On Poorly Waxed Floor At Bank $900 Thousand Verdict For Medical Malpractice $103 Million

Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyers

Choosing the right Law firm matters.

Have you been injured in a Staten Island accident? You may be entitled to compensation. Money may not guarantee a full recovery. However, it can be incredibly helpful during this difficult time. You will need the help of a skilled Staten Island personal injury lawyer if you want to maximize your recovery. At Sgarlato Law Personal Injury Lawyer, we will fight to make sure that you get the money you deserve.


Why Should I Hire a Personal Injury Attorney?

So, you’ve decided that you want to file a lawsuit. That’s an important first step. The next thing you should do is hire an experienced attorney. You may be able to get some money on your own. However, if you want to maximize your award or settlement you need to let a personal injury attorney handle your case.

1. You need to focus on your physical recovery.

Personal injury cases can be complicated and time-consuming. If you’ve suffered a serious injury you need to focus all of your time and energy on getting better. You can’t do this if you are trying to navigate a complex legal claim.

Hiring a Staten Island personal injury lawyer who understands applicable law and procedure is a great solution. You can focus on your recovery while knowing that your case is in good hands.

2. You’re not sure what your claim is worth.

It can be difficult to properly value a personal injury case. Insurance companies are known for low-balling accident victims. If you don’t hire an attorney you will be forced to rely on an insurance company’s calculations. They will do whatever they can do minimize your financial award. Hiring a Staten Island personal injury lawyer can protect you from these devious practices. Our attorneys will make sure that the extent of your injuries and the value of your claim are assessed properly. We work with experts throughout New Yoork to make sure that you get the money you deserve.

3. You may not know who is responsible for your injuries.

In some cases, more than one person can be responsible for causing you harm. Our attorneys will thoroughly investigate your accident and pinpoint who may be at fault. This could include companies, government agencies, employers, and property owners, and other third parties. We will pursue compensation from anyone who may have caused you harm.

4. It’s important to level the playing field.

It can be difficult to properly value a personal injury case. Insurance companies are known for low-balling accident victims. If you don’t hire an attorney you will be forced to rely on an insurance company’s calculations. They will do whatever they can do minimize your financial award. Hiring a Staten Island personal injury lawyer can protect you from these devious practices. Our attorneys will make sure that the extent of your injuries and the value of your claim are assessed properly. We work with experts throughout New York to make sure that you get the money you deserve.

Why Should I File a Personal Injury Claim?

The average cost of a personal injury claim following a car accident is about $15,785. If your injury is severe you can expect to pay a whole lot more.

In fact, you may be faced with tens of thousands, if not millions, of dollars in medical bills. Most Americans do not have enough saved away to cover these extraordinary costs. Fortunately, you have the right to file a lawsuit if someone else caused your accident. We will help you get the money you deserve. We won’t rest until you are fairly compensated for your injuries.


Practice Areas

Personal Injury

For someone who is unfamiliar with the area of personal injury law, it can be a confusing subject. What are the statutes of limitations on the various types of personal injury cases and how to those change if it is a case brought against the government? Should I give any information to the insurance company or discuss the case in any way? The area of personal injury law can be a minefield that is impossible to navigate if you don’t have experienced professionals on your side.

Construction Accidents

At Sgarlato and Sgarlato, we have years of experience in handling a variety of Staten Island personal injury cases. We have the expertise you need to get the best possible results for your case. Whether your case involves a government entity or a private individual, you need to contact the expert Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyers at Sgarlato and Sgarlato because time is not on your side in a personal injury case.

Medical Malpractice

If there is one person people trust implicitly outside of their own family members it is their doctor. When that doctor recommends their patient go see a specialist, that patient also trusts the specialist implicitly. When a doctor violates that trust, it can be emotionally devastating for the patient. But more than that, it can also be fatal.

Legal Malpractice

It takes a special kind of law firm to be the legal malpractice attorney Staten Island residents and business professionals count on. But for many years now, Sgarlato and Sgarlato has been the legal malpractice lawyer Staten Island clients have been counting for honest and comprehensive representation.

Slip & Fall Accidents

Slip and fall accidents are among the most common personal injury cases in the U.S. They can occur when fluids or ice cover the ground where people walk on. Slip and fall accidents can cause injuries to the back of the head, neck, and back. These injuries can be severe and can affect the overall quality of life.

Trip & Fall Accidents

Trip and fall accidents can occur due to uneven surfaces or objects on the floor. Broken sidewalks or poorly placed objects on the floor can cause a trip and fall that can lead to injuries to the front of the head or face, hands, arms, or elbows. These injuries could be severe and could affect someone’s overall quality of life.


Car Accidents

Each year, around 1,000 people die due to an auto accident here in New York. Many more face an accident which leads to severe and lasting bodily injuries. Experiencing an injury due to an auto accident may cause a lot of pain, suffering, and confusion. Insurance companies can be unfair and your quality of life could be considerably affected.


Why Get Services of a Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyer?

Injuries and accidents never knock on our door announced. They tend to ambush us. In such times, it makes perfect sense to get the services of a Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyer. Here’s why you should get in touch with personal injury lawyers on Staten Island.

We Offer Objective and Professional Advice

Personal injuries, including car accidents, bring forth a lot of emotional trauma and pain. During this phase, it is naturally tough to make objective and informed decisions pertaining to the injury/ accident on your own. With a personal injury lawyer Staten Island by your side, you will find it easy to move forward responsibly.

Your Staten Island personal injury lawyer will oversee the legal work on your behalf. From deciding the best route forward to filing the personal injury claims to ensuring you get the right compensation- your lawyer will take care of it all.

Moreover, an expert personal injury lawyer in Staten Island also brings great experience, knowledge, and skill to the table. This increases your chances of getting the reasonable settlement you deserve according to your case.

We Provide Great Legal Coverage

The offending party may contest personal injury claims if your personal injury involves another party. Consequently, this pushes you towards some legal action. If the other party has a lawyer, and you are without one, the odds will only be against you. Getting an expert Staten Island personal injury lawyer in this situation is your best bet!

Having the guidance and constant support of a skilled personal injury lawyer on Staten Island will certainly level the playing field for you. Your personal injury lawyer will give you enough legal representation after any such event, including car accidents.

Your lawyer will gather all the required documents and evidence to help you win the court case. If you are alone in this scenario, you will likely panic. With a professional Staten Island personal injury lawyer at your back, you will feel confident and strong. 

We Can Help You Attain Fair Compensation Fast

 There may come a time when you need legal advice for a personal injury claim. If you are fighting alone at this time, you will likely have to wait a long time to get fair compensation. Fortunately, things change for the better if you have the guidance of a Staten Island, personal injury lawyer.

Our lawyers are well-aware of the entire drill. They know the ins and outs of the legal world and have the right strategies up their sleeve to help you out.  Your personal injury lawyer has likely experience similar situations and cases.

Knowing the legalities involved in such cases can help you sidestep the obstacles so you quickly get your rightful compensation. Get legal advice and services from a qualified Staten Island, personal injury lawyer today.


What is considered a personal injury?

A personal injury is an injury you experience at the hands of someone else’s recklessness or negligence. It can entitle you to receive different kinds of financial compensation for your pain and any injury-related expenses.

What is personal injury law?

Personal Injury Law, aka Tort Law, is created to safeguard you and your rights if you or any of your property undergoes any harm due to somebody else’s carelessness and irresponsible behavior. The law also allows the sufferer to take legal action in such circumstances and get compensation for suffering any loss or losses.

What is a statute of limitations in personal injury law?

There are some statutes of limitations in personal injury law. In case of personal injury, two years after the injury has been caused. In case the injury wasn’t discovered promptly, it is one year from the exact date the injury got identified. Breach of written contract: about four years from the date the contract was breached.


Types of Compensation Available in Personal Injury Cases 

Each case is unique in its own right. That said, based on your case, the evidence gathered, and the skill of the Staten Island personal injury lawyer you have hired, you can get financial compensation for different types of damages as explained below:

  • Pain & Suffering: You can claim compensation if your injuries caused you mental or physical pain or loss of excitement in life.
  • Future Pain & Suffering: With permanent injuries, you can claim a reasonable sum of money for the suffering and pain you’ll suffer in the long term.
  • Medical Bills: Injuries lead to hospital stays, prescriptions, and treatments. In case of expensive health care bills, you can claim for medical expenses.
  • Lost Wages: You are eligible to collect compensation for lost tips, bonuses, and wages for missing time from work due to your injuries.
  • Reduced Earning Capacity: if your personal injury obstructs your earning capacity in the future, you can claim money to compensate for the earning potential you lost.
  • Losing Loved Ones: An expert Staten Island personal injury lawyer can help you recover the expenses involved in the funeral and burial of a loved one you lost in an accident.

Make sure to discuss your case with an adept Staten Island personal injury lawyer, so they can help you get the compensation you deserve.

Our Office

Our Attorneys

Gina Sgarlato

Gina Sgarlato

Managing Partner

Gina M. Sgarlato, Staten Island Personal Injury Attorney is the managing partner of Sgarlato & Sgarlato. With 22 years of experience, she has represented clients in a wide range of actions and leads the legal team in preparing each case for trial and resolution. Under her stewardship, Sgarlato & Sgarlato, PLLC has grown to be one of Staten Island’s most respected law firms.

Read More

Michael D. Fitzgerald

Michael D. Fitzgerald

Senior Associate

Michael D. Fitzgerald is the Senior Associate at Sgarlato & Sgarlato. He has been an Associate at the firm since his admission to the Bar in January 2002. His substantial experience in the litigation of personal injury and medical malpractice matters allows him to handle all aspects of these cases for the firm’s clients from inception through trial. This includes drafting court documents, pre-trial discovery, conducting depositions, and drafting and arguing motions.

Read More

Mahnoor Syed

Mahnoor Syed


Mahnoor Syed is the Associate Attorney at Sgarlato & Sgarlato. After law school, Mahnoor began her legal career and joined the firm, where she had a valuable experience learning the fundamentals of personal injury cases. Upon passing the bar exam in 2020, she transitioned into an attorney role and has gained a substantial amount of experience in personal injury and medical malpractice matters.

Read More

Over 50 years of combined experience
in complex legal matters

At Sgarlato and Sgarlato, we are Staten Island personal injury lawyers dedicated to our clients and will fight to ensure a fair and equitable outcome. Our attorneys have more than 50 years of combined experience. Sgarlato & Sgarlato’s exceptional results for our clients lie in the expertise, professionalism and ingenuity of each of our exceptionally qualified attorneys.The results we achieve for our clients often make headlines.

Success Stories

Because of Mr. Sgarlato, my life is changing for the better. The award we won against the hospital will help me do whatever I want to do in life and give me a little more freedom.

- Stephanie Debes

I’ve known Richard and Gina Sgarlato for thirty years and rely on them to handle every kind of legal issue. They assist me and my family in real estate matters and property investments.
- Dennis Gambino

During one of the most painful times in my life, the Sgarlato firm corrected the mistakes of another law firm and obtained the best possible result in the wrongful death of my husband.

- Carol Spatola

Get In Touch


    Contact Us

    Office: (718) 273-7900

    Fax: (718) 273-9629

    Office Hours

    Mon-Fri: 9am – 5pm
    Sat-Sun: By appointment
    Evening hours available by appointment


    1444 Clove Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301

    The Story Of Lavern’s Law

    In January 2018, the state of New York passed an amendment to its discovery rule related to medical malpractice cases involving cancer misdiagnosis. New York was previously known for having a short statute of limitations, making it challenging for cancer patients to...

    How Do You Sue a School District?

    Sending a child to school is a routine part of life for most parents, and it's natural to expect that the school district will provide a safe and nurturing environment for their child's education. Unfortunately, this is not always the case, and incidents of...

    My Photo Is Used Without My Permission; Can I Sue?

    Imagine you're comfortably sitting on your chair, browsing the internet or reading a magazine when suddenly you come across a photo of yourself. The catch? You never authorized anyone to use your image, and you didn't post it on that website. It's frustrating to...

    Can I Sue If My Child Was Injured at a New York City Public School?

    Getting your child enrolled in a public school in New York is often a necessity. But what happens when the inevitable strikes? What would you do if your child was injured at school? Sometimes, what often follows after receiving a call about your child being injured is...

    What is a private nuisance?

    Have you ever had a neighbor who played loud music at all hours of the night, or who left their barking dog outside to disturb the peace? Or perhaps you've been on the receiving end of an offensive odor from a nearby factory, or suffered through excessive vibrations...

    A Story Of Bad Driving In New York State

    The sound of screeching tires and shattering glass pierced the peaceful night in a quiet New York City neighbourhood. What followed was a scene of chaos and destruction, as a reckless driver plowed his parents' Mercedes into the home of two elderly sisters, causing...

    Why Does A Lawyer’s Experience Matter?

    When it comes to choosing a lawyer, there are many factors to consider. You want someone who is knowledgeable, skilled, and who can represent you effectively in court. But there's one factor that often gets overlooked: experience. While it may be tempting to go with a...

    Are Unwanted Facebook Photos An Invasion Of Your Privacy?

    Social media has become an integral part of our daily lives, with platforms like Facebook allowing us to connect with friends and family worldwide. However, with this increased connectivity comes an increased risk to our privacy. One common issue on Facebook is...

    Slip & Fall Accidents- The Difference between Negligence And Carelessness

    Slip and fall accidents are a prevalent cause of personal injury lawsuits in the United States. Despite often being perceived as minor incidents, they can result in severe injuries that require medical treatment and cause significant financial burdens. Such accidents...

    Can I sue for Massage Injuries?

    Picture this: You've been feeling tense and stressed out lately, so you decide to treat yourself to a relaxing massage at a local spa. The lights are dim, the music is soothing, and you're finally starting to unwind - until you feel a sharp pain in your neck. You...